Why are Attractor Fly Patterns Effective?

I’ve been sitting at my fly tying vise this week working on flies for our upcoming trip to Patagonia. All the flies are Fat Alberts in a couple of sizes and colors. My mind wanders a lot when tying and I started to think why are attractor fly patterns effective?

Fat Albert Flies | www.johnkreft.com

I featured this fly last year as a Throw Back Thursday Fly. I found it was initially used to imitate Cantaria beetle in Chile. But why would it be effective in a lot of other waters?

Sure, I can understand how a large black fly might trick a trout into thinking it was eating a beetle, but why eat a brown/tan version? I know what you are thinking…grasshopper, right?

Here is a link to my RiverKeeper Flies YouTube channel where I demonstrate tying the fly.

Or if you like to be entertained, here is a video of me “speed tying”. I have a 30 minute limit on my camera when creating videos and decided to see how many I could tie. It’s just over 5 minutes long.

When I think about attractor fly patterns, the one that comes to mind is a Parachute Adams. I don’t use it much, but I know other fly fishers do with great success.

Parachute Adams | www.johnkreft.com

How about a Purple Haze?

Purple Haze | www.riverkeeperflies.com

Or this Royal Wulff?

Royal Wulff No Vise | www.johnkreft.com

Or a Chubby Chernobyl in purple?

Chubby Chernobyl - Purple | www.johnkreft.com

Why are they successful? I’m not sure.

When matching the hatch, I generally use the theory of size, profile, and color as the basic characteristics to consider when selecting flies. I believe the order is important.

I don’t have a lot of answers, only questions.

Back to the vise so random thoughts can bounce around in my head! I have a few more size 8 Fat Alberts to tie in black.

Enjoy…go fish!

Similar Posts

  • Atherton No.1 Dry Fly

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is the Atherton No.1 dry fly. John Atherton (1900 – 1952) was an artist by trade and incorporated his impressionistic art into the flies he tied. The hackle of the Atherton No. 1 are all mixed colors to create a life-like fly imitating the real insects. Interestingly, he didn’t…

  • PMD Hatch

    I was on the river recently and was pleased to see a terrific PMD hatch. Yes, it’s that time of year when Pale Morning Duns hatch in droves and the fish are eager to eat them off the surface. I looked back at previous posts and sure enough, I’ve written about these flies in late…

  • Stalcup’s Emergent Cripple Dun

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is Stalcup’s Emergent Cripple Dun. I decided it was time to feature another Shane Stalcup fly. I first learned of Stalcup’s flies in his book Mayflies “Top to Bottom” (2002). I thought it was interesting looking at the materials he used to create close imitations to the real insects. It was…

  • Royal Coachman Dry Fly

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is the classic Royal Coachman dry fly. This attractor fly pattern is one that many older fly fishers recognize. It truly is a classic! It was one of many flies I found in a friend’s old fly box. There are many variations to the first Royal Coachman, which was…

  • Happy New Year 2019

    Happy New Year 2019 everyone. I thought today’s post would be a good time to take a look back at 2018. I’d like to express my gratitude to all the RiverKeeper Flies subscribers and readers who have found me one way or another. 2018 has been another good year.

  • Filling Customer Fly Orders

    I’ve been at the fly tying desk lately working hard filling customer fly orders as well as the provider box. I thought this week’s post would highlight a few flies that have been coming off my vise. Some of the popular requests lately have been Clark’s Lady Stone, Improved Sparkle Dun – PMD, Hemingway Caddis,…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *