More Mayfly Spinners

A couple of weeks ago, I wrote about PMD spinner fly patterns and shared the Ellis Triple Wing Spinner as a TBT post. Spinners have continued to be a focus in my fly fishing and fly tying. I thought I’d share a few more mayfly spinners.

Spinner fishing can be terrific. But locating the spinners and finding when a spinner fall happens, and if the fish are eating them can be tricky.

Here is an image of a spinner I recently found floating in a side eddy.

Mayfly Spinner | www.johnkreft.com

Notice how the clear, reflective wings are splayed flat on the water. Most fly patterns emulate this profile.

Another image of the same insect.

Mayfly Spinner with Spayed Wings

Eddies are a great collection point for insects floating down the river and available to fish. I’d call them little food conveyors. If you spend time watching an eddy, pay attention to the insects floating along the edges. It will provide insights about what insects are available to the trout.

Collecting Insects | www.johnkreft.com

Some days you won’t find any insects at all. Other days, this is what you’ll find.

Insects Found in Eddy | www.johnkreft.com

The image above doesn’t include any spinners, but it’s an example of what you can find if you pay attention.

Here is an image of the spinner wings in upright position.

Mayfly Spinner | www.johnkreft.com

Mayfly spinners are not easy to find as they float down river. Sometimes it is easier to see them if you get closer to the water, perhaps wading. This is a Rusty Spinner, the last phase of a PMD.

Rusty Spinner | www.johnkreft.com

And a Green Drake Spinner

Green Drake Spinner on Water | www.johnkreft.com

Notice how the wings are together and the insect is floating sideways in the water.

Another image of a Green Drake spinner.

Green Drake Spinner | www.johnkreft.com

I continued to tie up some Galloup’s Compara Spinner last week.

Here is a variant using turkey biots for the body.

Galloup's Compara Spinner - Biot Body Bottom View | www.johnkreft.com

It’s a fly I plan to use when I have problems finding the Rusty Spinner – Biot Body.

Rusty Spinner Biot Body | www.johnkreft.com

We’ve just started fishing Galloup’s Compara Spinner and it’s tricked one fish so far. I like the way it floats in the water, plus it’s very visible with the Compara Dun style wing!

Galloup's Compara Spinner - Front View | www.johnkreft.com

The differences between the two flies are minimal, but adding the wing may be all it takes to make it easier picking up the fly floating on the water.

On the water.

Galloup's Compara Spinner on the Water | www.johnkreft.com

This might be my new favorite spinner pattern. Like many flies I fish, I pick a style and tie it in different sizes and colors. My RiverKeeper Soft Hackle Cripple and the famous Sparkle Dun are two examples of flies I fish contently to imitate any mayfly.

Here are links to a few other posts I’ve created over the years about the mayfly life cycle and spinners:

Enjoy…go fish, stay safe!

Similar Posts

  • Sidewinder No-Hackle

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is the Sidewinder No-Hackle, by Doug Swisher and Carl Richards. This size 18 fly was given to me recently by a friend who tied it a few years ago. I think he did a terrific job! Notice the small drop of Dave’s Fleximent at the tip of the wing,…

  • Pink Lady

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is the Pink Lady, a classic Catskill fly. This Pink Lady was tied by Bob Kern at the International Federation of Fly Fishers Fair in Livingston, MT in August 2016. Bob did an amazing job of mounting the wings, utilizing the double-slip quill wing style. He drove all the way to…

  • Improved Governor

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is the Improved Governor. This is another steelhead fly found in John Shewey’s Classis Steelhead Flies book. It’s one of my sources of flies for TBT posts. I’ve read recently about the low steelhead returns in the Columbia Basin and it got me thinking about the last time I…

  • Fly Fishing Around Trocoman House

    During our time at Chochoy Mallin, we fished two different beats on the Rio Trocoman. I hope you read yesterday’s post where I shared out experience on a section farther upstream. We decided to spend the night and enjoyed our fly fishing around Trocoman House with SET Fly Fishing. That’s right, we’re wearing our waders…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *