Have you ever been fly fishing at Diamond Lake? We had an opportunity to meet friends Debbi, Philip, Carol & Kim at a cabin on Diamond Lake last weekend. And we took it!

It has been a couple of months since we did a little lake fishing.

We first fished Diamond Lake in 2008 with our friend Tim. I think it was the second year the lake re-opened after killing all the fish due to bait fish (tui chub) taking it over. This is what happens when someone fishes with illegal live bait. In 2009, we caught so many of these fish.

Diamond Lake Rainbow | www.johnkreft.com

And then this slippery little devil. The fish were strong in AND out of the water!

Slippery Diamond Lake Rainbow | www.johnkreft.com

We fished it last in June 2012. The fishing wasn’t as good as previous years due to the regulation changes allowing an increase in harvest and year-round fishing. In the meantime, East Lake started fishing better after the population of Tui Chub were reduced and oh boy…the Callibaetis mayflies hatching at East Lake are a sight to behold!

We had planned to fish Friday after we arrived, but the lake looked like this…

Diamond Lake Storm | www.johnkreft.com

You may not be able to see the white-caps out on the lake. A fire at the cabin sounded a lot better.

Planning for the trip I decided to tie a few more of my favorite lake fly – Denny’s Stillwater Nymph.

Denny's Stillwater Nymph | www.johnkreft.com

I don’t know why this fly works so well, but it certainly is a fish catcher! It’s my go-to searching lake pattern. I also tie and fish the fly with an olive marabou wingcase.

Dennys Stillwater Nymph - Olive Wingcase | www.johnkreft.com

Denny’s Stillwater Nymph has accounted for many a fish.

And an olive Zebra Midge worked well when we used to fish Diamond Lake. Chironomid fishing isn’t my favorite style of fly fishing, but there is no getting around how effective it can be. I’ve been around boats fishing Chironomids and they were the only ones catching fish.

So when I go to the dark side, I usually start with an olive Zebra Midge as one of my flies.

Zebra Midge | www.johnkreft.com

On Saturday, we fished both versions of Denny’s Stillwater Nymph and the fish liked them equally well. Big or small fish…it didn’t seem to make any difference.

And speaking of big fish, here are a couple…

20″ Rainbow

Diamond Lake 23 Inch Rainbow | www.johnkreft.com

20″ Rainbow

Diamond Lake Rainbow | www.johnkreft.com

We ended up hooking an playing 28 fish between the two of us, landing 18. Not exactly like a few years ago.

But it was a good day!

Enjoy…go fish!

Note: In 2006, Diamond Lake was treated with rotenone to eliminate an estimated 90 million of the tui chub.

A couple other things: 

  • If you’d like to receive an email when a new Post is published, be sure to sign up in the SUBSCRIBE area on the sidebar of this page. 
  • Check out the Fly Patterns page as I continue to add patterns I fish. Don’t tie? That’s OK. Many of these patterns can be found in your local fly shop or send me a Comment for more information about how to purchase RiverKeeper Flies. 
  • Feel free to share with this post with your friends by copying the link to RiverKeeper Flies (www.johnkreft.com), or using the buttons below to SHARE on Facebook, Twitter, Google+, or pin pictures to Pinterest
  • If you’d like to follow me on Facebook, click Follow RiverKeeper Flies on the sidebar where I add a few pictures and thoughts.
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Similar Posts

One Comment

  1. Sounds like fun! To bad diamond could not have continued to be what it was a few years ago.. Damed wind is always a problem.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.