Select the Right Dry Fly

How do you select the right dry fly to tie on the end of your leader? Here are a few tips to make the selection process a little easier the next time you’re at the river.

Let’s make it simple. You arrive at the river and it’s your lucky day, bugs are hatching. You were dreaming about this last night, anticipating your upcoming fishing trip. So let’s talk about selecting a dry fly.

Is it a mayfly with upright wings?

Caudatella Mayfly|www.johnkreft.com

How about a caddis with tent-shaped wings?

Caddis | www.johnkreft.com

Or perhaps a stonefly with fluttering wings over the body?

Salmonfly adult|www.johnkreft.com

Notice I concentrated on the wings? That’s what fly fishers call “profile”. 

Need an imitation for a mayfly? Try a Sparkle Dun, a classic Adams, or a Parachute Adams.

Sparkle Dun - March Brown|www.johnkreft.com

Adams | www.johnkreft.com

Parachute Adams | www.johnkreft.com

A classic caddis imitation is an Elk Hair Caddis.

Elk Hair Caddis|www.johnkreft.com

And a stonefly imitation – the Clarks Stone or a Rogue Foam Stonefly.

Clark's Golden Stone | www.johnkreft.com
Rogue Foam Stone | www.johnkreft.com

After selecting the profile, size and color come next.

Just match your fly’s size to the real bug. If you don’t have exactly the right color, that’s OK. Find the closest color in your fly box and tie it on. It might work.

Are the fish super-selective today? Then color might be important.

Those are the basic concepts I use to select the right dry fly. I use it all the time. Be sure to check out one of my popular posts New to Fly Fishing? What Flies Should I Use? for more ideas for a few flies to start fishing with.

In a future post, I’ll describe the importance of fly style (impressionistic vs. imitative) in the selection process for the waters you fish.

Now get out there and practice!

Enjoy…go fish!

A couple other things: 

  • If you’d like to receive an email when a new Post is published, be sure to sign up in the SUBSCRIBE area on the sidebar of this page. 
  • Check out the Fly Patterns page as I continue to add patterns I fish. Don’t tie? That’s OK. Many of these patterns can be found in your local fly shop or send me a Comment for more information about how to purchase RiverKeeper Flies. 
  • Feel free to share with your friends by copying the link to RiverKeeper Flies (www.johnkreft.com), or using the buttons below to SHARE on Facebook, Twitter, Google+, or pin pictures to Pinterest
  • If you’d like to follow me on Facebook, click Follow RiverKeeper Flies on the sidebar where I add a few pictures and thoughts.

Similar Posts

  • Chernobyl Ant

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is the Chernobyl Ant. It’s an attractor fly pattern and can imitate cicada, crickets, grasshoppers, and stoneflies. Larry Tullis of Orem, Utah relays the fly’s development in Tying Flies with Foam, Fur, and Feathers by Harrison Steeves. Larry tied up a foam body cicada from a beach sandal in the late…

  • Denny Rickards Seal Bugger

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is Denny Rickards Seal Bugger. Denny created this fly in the mid-80’s on Oregon’s Upper Klamath Lake, his home waters. The fly is a variation of the popular Woolly Bugger.  I’d seen this fly years ago, but found it again in Rickards Fly-Fishing Stillwaters for Trophy Trout (1997). It’s the…

  • Atherton No. 2 Dry Fly

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is the Atherton No. 2 dry fly. I’ve highlighted a couple other Atherton flies recently, the Atherton No. 5 and Atherton No. 3. John Atherton (1900 – 1952) was an artist by trade and incorporated his impressionistic art into the flies he tied. The tail, body, and hackle of…

  • Ray Bergman Dark Spinner

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is the Ray Bergman Dark Spinner. The Ray Bergman Dark Spinner is a wet fly listed in his book entitled Trout (1940 – fourth printing) on page 38, Plate No. 2. I usually tie just one fly for my TBT posts. I’m not trying to make them perfect, just…

  • Mike Jacobs’ Blonde Goddess

    This week’s Throw Back Thursday Fly is Mike Jacobs’ Blonde Goddess. I learned about this fly from a customer asking if I could tie the fly for him. He planned to fish for rainbow trout in the 14 to 24 inch range on a local river and thought this fly might work. Jacobs originally tied…

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *