Last week, I presented a program about John “Jack” Atherton on BT’s Fly Tying Friday. I’ve always been intrigued by fly tiers from an earlier era, especially those whose names and contributions may not be familiar to many who read my RiverKeeper Flies posts. Over the years, I’ve shared many of their patterns in my Throw Back Thursday Flies series. There was something about Atherton’s flies that really spoke to me, and I thought his “appearance of life” dry flies would make an interesting subject for one of my Zoom fly tying classes.

I featured Atherton’s dry flies after reading about him in Mike Valla’s The Founding Flies book. These Catskill-style flies have been favorites to tie and I’ve featured them in my Throw Back Thursday Flies.
Here’s a link to the presentation on my RiverKeeper Flies YouTube channel. Below the video, I’ve included the slides from my PowerPoint presentation, along with a few comments and explanations to provide additional context and share my thoughts.
The slide below highlights Atherton’s philosophy and what he hoped to achieve through the development of his flies.

In the next six slides, I share close-up photographs of insects I’ve captured that illustrate what I believe Atherton meant by his concept of the “appearance of life.”






The next slide briefly highlights fly tying materials Atherton used to create his “appearance of life” concept.

And the Atherton No. 1 through Atherton No. 6 flies I’ve tied and shared as Throw Back Thursday Flies posts. Click the links below to learn more about each pattern.
Sources:
- The Founding Flies by Mike Valla – Chapter 9
- The Fly and the Fish by John Atherton
- Fly Tyer magazine (Autumn 2026) – Tyer profile – Dave McNeese (page 58)
I shared the Dette Hackle Guage and how I use the proportions shown under the heading: Winged Catskill Dry.

The next slide compares the dubbing mixture I created with materials listed for the Atherton No. 2 fly pattern with dubbing sold from Dette Flies. I don’t believe the Classic Dubbing incorporates seal and probably includes synthetic material.

The next slide compares the dubbing mixture I created with materials listed for the Atherton No. 4 fly pattern with dubbing sold from Dette Flies. Again, I don’t believe the Classis Dubbing incorporates seal and probably includes synthetic material.

This is an Atherton quote I ended with and the next two slides highlight the wonderful capes and saddles we are lucky to tie with in 2026.

Lastly, here are two images from my September 2022 Feathers, Feathers, Feathers post to highlight the variety of hackle available today.


Enjoy…go fish!













John’s presentation on Fly Tying Friday was AWESOME!!!
Tight Lines – Gretchen & Al Beatty
I grew up and started fly fishing in the Catskills. This brought back a lot of memories and I always tied and fished Catskill style dries. Stopped in the Dette’s quite a few times. thank you so much.
Thanks for leaving a comment Bob.
John